Elevate Your Dining Experience: Ordering Oysters and Champagne

Nestled in the heart of Marco Island, The Oyster Society stands as a testament to the culinary excellence that defines Florida's coastal dining scene. With its commitment to showcasing the finest seafood, including delectable oysters, and a carefully curated wine list, The Oyster Society offers an unparalleled dining experience.

The Oyster Society Experience

Before diving into the ordering process, it's essential to understand the unique ambiance and offerings of The Oyster Society. This upscale seafood restaurant combines chic, coastal décor with breathtaking waterfront views, creating an inviting and sophisticated atmosphere. The knowledgeable staff is dedicated to providing impeccable service, making your visit a memorable one.

Oysters: The Stellar Stars

The Oyster Society prides itself on sourcing the freshest oysters from various regions, allowing diners to embark on a culinary journey through the oyster-rich waters of North America. Be sure to inquire about the daily oyster selection, which can include favorites like Apalachicola, Blue Point, or Kumamoto oysters, each with its distinct flavor profile.

Ordering Oysters

1. Oyster Variety: Start by asking your server about the oyster selection for the day. They can provide insights into the unique characteristics of each variety, helping you make an informed choice.

2. Accompaniments:  Consider your preferred oyster accompaniments. The Oyster Society offers classic options like cocktail sauce, mignonette, and fresh lemon wedges. Don't hesitate to ask for recommendations on pairings.

3. Quantity: Oysters are often ordered by the half-dozen or dozen. Depending on your appetite and the number of varieties you wish to sample, make your selection accordingly.

Champagne: Bubbles of Luxury

The Oyster Society's wine list is a treasure trove of options, but when it comes to oysters, champagne is the ultimate choice. The restaurant offers a selection of champagne and sparkling wines to complement your oyster experience. The crisp acidity and refreshing bubbles of champagne serve as a delightful counterpoint to the richness of oysters, creating a harmonious marriage of flavors on the palate.

Pairing Oysters and Champagne

Pairing oysters and champagne is a delicate art that elevates the dining experience. Here are some tips to create a memorable combination:

  1. Brut Champagne: Opt for a brut champagne, which is dry and crisp, as it complements the oysters' natural salinity. The champagne's acidity enhances the oyster's flavors without overpowering them.

  2. Regional Matching: Consider regional pairings. Apalachicola oysters, for example, harmonize beautifully with a French champagne like Veuve Clicquot, while Indian River Lagoon oysters may find their perfect match in a drier option like Dom Pérignon.

  3. Texture Play: Champagne's effervescence and acidity can cut through the creamy texture of raw oysters, creating a delightful contrast. The bubbles cleanse the palate, preparing it for the next succulent bite.

  4. Garnish Thoughtfully: Pay attention to the garnishes and condiments you use with your oysters. Lemon zest, mignonette sauce, or a dash of hot sauce can enhance the pairing experience.

  5. Champagne Selection: Consult the restaurant's wine menu to explore their champagne and sparkling wine offerings. A brut champagne is a classic choice for oysters, but feel free to ask the sommelier for personalized recommendations based on your preferences.

  6. Glass or Bottle: Depending on your party size and enthusiasm for champagne, you can order by the glass or choose a bottle to share. Sharing a bottle can be a wonderful way to savor the experience with friends or loved ones.

The Perfect Pairing

Once you've made your selections, sit back and savor the exquisite combination of oysters and champagne. The refreshing effervescence of champagne complements the briny succulence of oysters, creating a harmonious dance of flavors on your palate.

Dining at The Oyster Society in Marco Island is an opportunity to indulge in the finest seafood and experience the luxurious marriage of oysters and champagne. By following these guidelines for ordering, you'll ensure that your visit to this esteemed establishment is a gastronomic adventure to remember, where every bite and sip embodies the essence of coastal elegance.

Follow Us

Try our Sunset Menu before the sun sets on this summer!🌅 Trust us, you won’t want to miss out...

This menu consists of some of our all-time favorite items! Want to mix & match? For only $45, you can choose one small bite, a soup or salad, AND an entree. Plus, 25% off bottles of wine under $100!

Available Sunday-Thursday from 4:30-6PM.✨ Check out our Sunset menu online or through the link in our story.
An oyster a day…🦪

Enjoy an incredible selection of raw oysters available daily. In fact, we have one of the largest selections of oysters in the US! Ask your server for a list of what’s being shucked today.


599 South Collier Blvd., #218
Marco Island, Florida 34145


Open Daily 4:30pm until Volume

Explore our other restaurants

© 2024 The Oyster Society

Designed + Powered by South Made